2:14-26. Faith and actions work together
A problem similar to that which James deals with in
this passage was found both in the religion of Israel and later Judaism. The
Old Testament prophets had spoken out against people who took part in public
worship and offered sacrifices to God but who did not show their loyalty to the
law of the Mosaic Covenant in their day-to-day life. They disregarded the moral
teaching of the Covenant law which required honesty, justice, fair dealing and
moral attitudes generally in their dealings with others. Their public worship
was only a hypocritical show. There are many passages in the prophetic books
which condemn unjust, immoral and unloving behaviour on the part of those who
call themselves the people of God, for example, Amos
5:21-24, Micah 6:6-8, Hosea 4:1-2, Isaiah 1 :10-17, Jeremiah 7:1-11.
God was not deceived by mere outward professions of faith; he saw into the
inner self of the person, from where all evil came, as Jesus said in Mark 7:21-23.
Jesus condemned the hypocrisy of the Pharisees, in
his ministry in Galilee. Paul attacked a similar problem when he emphasized
that converts ought to show the results of their conversion in their day-to-day
living (Galatians 5:16-26 and 1 Corinthians 12, 13
and 14). Paul's emphasis is different from that of James. Paul
emphasized that the convert is changed by faith, enabling God jo work in him
and transform him by the power of the Holy Spirit. James emphasized that
without the signs of the changed character, mere verbal profession of faith
meant nothing. Paul teaches in both Galatians and Romans that a person is not
put right with God through his own unaided efforts, particularly with regard to
keeping the Jewish Law. God's grace alone, working through the faith which is
genuine commitment to God's will, puts a person right with God and offers him
salvation from the power of sin. But it is absolutely clear in Paul's teaching
that the step of faith should result in an observable transformation in the
convert. In the power of the Holy Spirit, a new life-style should be the
result. If it does not, then the one who professes conversion is not living a
life controlled by the Holy Spirit (Galatians 5:25).
James never speaks of the Holy Spirit, but there is
no contradiction with the teaching of Paul in what James says about faith
without actions. 'If it is alone and includes no actions,
then it is dead' (2: 17).
James leads into his argument about the relationship
of faith and actions by speaking very sarcastically of those who piously ask
for God's blessing on the poor who lack even the basic necessities of food and
clothing, but who do nothing at all to help the poor obtain what they need. How
will a hungry man with only rags to cover his nakedness feel when the well fed,
well dressed man says piously, 'God bless you! Keep
warm and eat well!' (2: 16) but offers the poor man nothing to
help him? It is possible that James was speaking from unfortunate experience of
a church congregation where there was an unhappy division among those who came
together for worship. There may have been well fed, well dressed, wealthy
members of the church and there may have been others who had to struggle to
keep alive, perhaps poor slaves lacking food, clothes and adequate shelter. It
may have been that those who lacked nothing ignored those who lacked almost
everything in contradiction to the teaching of the early Church about loving,
sharing and caring, as described in Acts 2:44-47 and 4:32-35.
What James says has a powerful application for the
modern Church There is awareness amongst many Christians of the need to share
re-sources with others who lack them and there are many Christian organizations
which do much to help the poor, but much more could be done. The Church, as the
world-wide community of the people of God, could bring much more pressure to
bear on the governments of the nations to focus attention on the need for much
fairer distribution of the world' resources. In all countries where Christians
are to be found, they have a responsibility to speak on behalf of all who are
oppressed, poor, home-less, hungry, handicapped and suffering. The church-goer
who says, 'It's not my business!' when confronted with suffering or injustice
in the society in which he lives, should remember the biting words of James in 2: 19, 'The
demons also believe!' 'Faith without
actions is dead' (2:26).
In 2:20-24,
James uses Abraham as an example of a man of true faith.
James takes the story of Abraham's willingness to
sacrifice his only son, the son of God's promise, if that was the will of God.
In his use of the story, James is arguing against mere intellectual assent or
verbal profession of faith which does not involve the intention and will of a
person. Abraham showed by his intention and action that he was totally
committed to the will of God even if this appeared superficially to be in
opposition to Abraham's own interests. It is possible that James had met people
in the early Church who, perhaps like Ananias and Sapphira (Acts 5: 1-11) professed faith publicly in
Jesus Christ but by their actions denied that they were totally committed to
following him.
James continues his argument in 2:25 by referring to
Rahab (Joshua 2 and 6), a woman who
showed compassion and courage in spite of being a Canaanite prostitute. 'She
was put right with God through her actions' (2:25).
2:26
The cananite prostitute
reminds the
readers of the Jewish-Christian teaching that body and spirit form the unity of
man's being (compare Paul's teaching in 1 Corinthians
12-15). There is an essential relationship between the spiritual
and the physical aspects of the human being. What man believes in his inner
spirit will be demonstrated in his outward actions.
·